Skip to main content

Wondering whether to share your brand’s stunning photo as an Instagram Post vs Story? Instagram Stories offer a 24-hour window of visibility, perfect for real-time engagement and ephemeral content. Instagram Posts, on the other hand, remain on your profile indefinitely. This will build a lasting image and reference point for your audience.

Consider your goals: is it instant interaction or prolonged exposure you’re after? Let’s explore the strategic choice between a Story and a Post to maximize your photo’s impact on Instagram. Keep in mind the algorithm’s preferences and the unique advantages each format offers.

Differences Between Instagram Stories and Posts

Understanding the positioning of different content types within the Instagram app is crucial for maximizing visibility and engagement. The Instagram algorithm suggests varying frequencies for posting Stories and feed posts. When deciding between an Instagram post vs story, it’s recommended to post Stories 2-3 times per day and feed posts 3-4 times per week.

While there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, a general guideline is to post Stories more frequently to keep your audience engaged daily, especially on days when you might not publish feed posts. Meta has indicated that Stories are effective tools for keeping audience members engaged between feed posts.

Appearance in the App

Understanding the positioning of different content types within the Instagram app is crucial for maximizing visibility and engagement.

Stories

Instagram stories - instagram post vs story

Stories are positioned at the very top of the Instagram app. This prime location ensures that they are one of the first things users see when they open the app. The prominent placement of Stories makes them highly visible and encourages users to engage with them frequently throughout the day. Because Stories are designed to be ephemeral, lasting only 24 hours, they create a sense of urgency. This often leads to higher engagement rates.

Stories also appeal to short attention spans and automatically play the next story, increasing the likelihood of viewers watching your content without actively deciding to do so.

Posts

Ig posts from WolfPack Advising's IG account - instagram post vs story

Posts, on the other hand, appear in your followers’ feeds as they scroll through Instagram. Though not as immediately visible as Stories, posts can still reach a wide audience with high engagement. Posts remain in your profile grid indefinitely, allowing for prolonged visibility and interaction over time. The Instagram algorithm prioritizes posts from accounts users engage with most.

By understanding these positioning strategies, you can better plan your content to ensure it reaches your audience effectively. For example, using Stories for timely updates and behind-the-scenes content can capture immediate attention, while leveraging posts for more permanent, high-quality content can build your brand presence over time.

Duration and Permanence

The duration and permanence of Instagram content significantly influence user interaction and perception.

Stories

Instagram Stories are designed to be temporary, lasting only 24 hours. This fleeting nature creates a sense of urgency, encouraging viewers to engage with the content before it disappears. Despite their temporary lifespan, Stories can be preserved by adding them to IG Highlights. Highlights are displayed prominently on your profile, allowing you to curate and showcase your favorite Stories indefinitely. This feature provides a balance between the ephemeral nature of Stories and the desire to keep important moments accessible to your audience.

Posts

In contrast to Stories, Instagram Posts are permanent fixtures on your profile. It is ideal for sharing high-quality, evergreen content. Unlike links in captions, which are not clickable on Instagram (unlike Facebook), Stories allow you to add a clickable link button, making it easy for viewers to take action.

Once uploaded, a post remains visible on your profile grid and in your followers’ feeds until you choose to delete it. This permanence makes posts ideal for sharing high-quality, evergreen content that represents your brand or personal identity. Permanent posts also contribute to your overall profile aesthetic and can be strategically used to tell a cohesive story or highlight key aspects of your brand.

Understanding the differences in duration and permanence between Stories and Posts allows you to strategically use each type of content to achieve your goals. For instance, use Stories for real-time updates, promotions, and behind-the-scenes glimpses, while leveraging posts for timeless content that builds your profile’s visual identity and long-term engagement.

Interactivity and Features

Understanding the interactive elements and features of Instagram content is essential for optimizing engagement and creating dynamic user experiences.

Stories

Rich with interactive features, Stories appeals to short attention spans and automatically play the next story, increasing the likelihood of viewers watching your content without actively deciding to do so. These features include:

Instagram Stories' interactive features - instagram post vs story
  • Polls: Allow your audience to vote on different options, making your content interactive and engaging.
  • Questions: Encourage your followers to ask questions, fostering direct communication and deeper engagement.
  • Quizzes: Create fun and educational quizzes to entertain and inform your audience.

When comparing Instagram post vs story, these interactive elements make Stories a powerful tool for real-time engagement, allowing you to interact with your audience in a more personal and immediate way. The interactive nature of Stories can also provide valuable insights into your audience’s preferences and opinions.

Posts

While Instagram Posts lack the interactive features found in Stories, they offer other benefits that can enhance your content strategy. Posts allow for:

  • Long Captions: With a character limit of up to 2,200 characters, you can share detailed stories, explanations, and context, making your content more informative and engaging.
  • Multiple Hashtags: Posts support the use of multiple hashtags, which can increase the discoverability of your content and reach a wider audience.

The ability to use long captions and multiple hashtags makes Posts ideal for sharing in-depth content, building your brand narrative, and increasing visibility on the platform.

By leveraging the unique features of both Stories and Posts, you can create a comprehensive Instagram strategy that maximizes engagement and reaches your audience effectively.

Content Format

The format and style of content you choose to share on Instagram can significantly impact how it is perceived and engaged with by your audience.

Stories

Instagram Stories are designed to be casual and ephemeral, making them perfect for real-time engagement. This format allows for more spontaneous, authentic content that gives followers a glimpse into the behind-the-scenes moments of your brand or daily life. Because Stories last only 24 hours, they create a sense of immediacy and urgency, encouraging quick and frequent interactions. The casual nature of Stories also allows for more creativity and experimentation without the pressure of long-term permanence.

  • Casual and Temporary: Stories offer a laid-back approach to content sharing, ideal for timely updates, quick polls, and engaging with your audience in the moment.

Posts

In contrast, Instagram Posts are more polished and evergreen. These pieces of content are crafted with a long-term perspective in mind and are meant to represent your brand or personal identity on a more permanent basis. Posts remain on your profile grid until you choose to delete them, contributing to the overall aesthetic and narrative of your profile. This format is well-suited for high-quality images, detailed captions, and content that adds lasting value to your audience.

  • Polished and Evergreen: Posts are designed to be high-quality and enduring, making them suitable for building a cohesive and visually appealing profile that stands the test of time.

Understanding the distinct formats of Stories and Posts allows you to use each type of content strategically. When considering Instagram post vs story, use Stories for casual, real-time engagement and Posts to create a lasting, polished presence on your profile. This balanced approach can help you connect with your audience on multiple levels and keep your content dynamic and engaging.

When to Use Instagram Posts

When considering an Instagram post vs story, Instagram posts are perfect for sharing significant business milestones, events, and core brand information. These evergreen posts tend to accumulate more views and likes over time, reinforcing your brand’s presence. For instance, Barclays Bank effectively uses posts to highlight its business achievements in London, creating a lasting impact on its audience.

Brand Awareness

Leverage posts for essential business milestones, events, and core brand information. Evergreen content can garner more views and likes as time progresses, aiding in ongoing brand awareness and engagement. Take Barclays Bank, which adeptly harnesses Instagram posts to spotlight its significant London business milestones and noteworthy events, imprinting a durable impact on its audience. In a similar vein, Wolfpack Advising employs Instagram posts to exhibit its triumphs, client success narratives, and pivotal events, maintaining a consistent and captivating brand presence.

WolfPark Advising and Barclays Bank brand awareness posts

Business Milestones and Events

Posts serve as an exceptional medium for broadcasting critical accomplishments and memorable junctures in your company’s journey.

Examples

  • Barclays Bank effectively uses Instagram posts to feature its London business milestones and important events, leaving a lasting impression on its audience.
  • Wolfpack Advising takes advantage of Instagram posts to display its achievements, client success stories, and key events, ensuring an engaging and consistent brand presence.
  • Nike often shares posts celebrating product launch anniversaries, harnessing nostalgia and customer loyalty.
  • Adobe creates posts that mark significant updates or releases in their software suite, keeping their user base informed and excited.
  • Airbnb leverages posts to commemorate partnerships with cities or tourism boards, enhancing their community-centric brand image.
  • Tesla broadcasts their technological advancements and sustainability milestones, aligning with their innovative and eco-friendly brand ethos.
  • Starbucks uses seasonal posts to mark the return of popular items, creating buzz and anticipation among customers.

Team Photos

Including team photos in your Instagram post grid can significantly enhance the authenticity and relatability of your brand. Visitors to your profile will appreciate seeing the faces behind your company, which helps to humanize your brand and build trust with your audience.

Authentic Team Photos

Sharing team photos in your post grid keeps your company’s presence genuine and personal. These photos give your followers a behind-the-scenes look at the people who make your brand what it is. Whether it’s candid shots from a company event or professional headshots, team photos create a more intimate connection with your audience. They help to showcase your company culture and values, making your brand more approachable and relatable.

Examples

  • Unlimit.com effectively uses team photos in their Instagram posts to highlight the individuals behind their brand. By regularly sharing images of their team members, they create a sense of community and authenticity that resonates with their audience. This approach not only puts faces to the brand but also fosters a stronger connection with its followers.
  • InVisionApp frequently shares team photos and behind-the-scenes snapshots on their Instagram profile. This strategy helps to illustrate their collaborative and innovative company culture, making their brand more relatable and engaging to their audience. By showcasing the real people behind their products, InVisionApp strengthens their brand’s credibility and trustworthiness.

By incorporating team photos into your Instagram strategy, you can enhance your brand’s authenticity and build a deeper relationship with your audience.

Product Information

Making core product guides, information, and tutorials easily accessible on your Instagram profile enhances user experience and long-term engagement.

Core Product Guides and Tutorials

Instagram Posts are the perfect medium for sharing detailed product guides, essential information, and step-by-step tutorials. These types of posts are evergreen, meaning they remain accessible and useful long after they are initially published. Keeping valuable content in your post grid provides a permanent resource for your audience. Use detailed captions, high-quality images, and instructional videos to create comprehensive guides users can reference anytime.

Examples

  • Starbucks exemplifies this strategy with their coffee brewing guides shared through Instagram posts. These guides, often run by Starbucks employees, provide detailed instructions on how to perfectly pair your favorite coffee with complementary foods and drinks. By posting these tutorials, Starbucks ensures that their customers have easy access to valuable content that enhances their coffee experience and strengthens their connection to the brand.
  • IKEA uses Instagram posts to share assembly instructions and product care guides. These posts provide visual step-by-step instructions and tips for assembling furniture and maintaining products, making it easier for customers to successfully use their purchases. By keeping these guides accessible on their profile, IKEA helps customers find important information quickly and efficiently, improving overall customer satisfaction. Additionally, IKEA shares posts about must-have items, offering recommendations on essential products that enhance living spaces, ensuring their customers are well-informed about the best options available for their needs.
  • Sephora frequently posts makeup tutorials and skincare routines on their Instagram profile. These tutorials, created by beauty experts and influencers, offer detailed guidance on using Sephora’s products effectively. By sharing these posts, Sephora provides their audience with valuable content that enhances their beauty routines and promotes their products engagingly and educationally.

When to Use Instagram Stories

Instagram Stories is an excellent tool for engaging with your audience in real-time. Their temporary nature and prominent placement within the app make them ideal for sharing timely and immediate content. Stories allow you to connect with your audience quickly and effectively, making them perfect for a variety of scenarios.

Timely and Breaking

When considering Instagram post vs story, Instagram Stories are perfect for instant updates and breaking news due to their 24-hour lifespan. This makes them an excellent choice for sharing timely information that requires immediate attention. The nature of Stories creates a sense of urgency and encourages your audience to engage with the content quickly before it disappears. Additionally, the interactive features available in Stories, such as polls and question stickers, can further enhance real-time engagement.

Example

  • CNN’s Breaking News Stories effectively uses Instagram Stories to share breaking news and updates. CNN can provide immediate coverage of events as they unfold, ensuring their audience stays informed with the latest news. The use of Stories allows CNN to deliver news in a fast, engaging, and visually appealing manner. This captures the attention of their followers and keeps them updated on important developments.
  • National Geographic’s Environmental Updates utilizes Instagram Stories to share timely updates on environmental issues and discoveries. Through their Stories, they provide real-time coverage of important events. For example, wildlife conservation efforts, climate change news, and scientific breakthroughs. Additionally, they educate people about unusual species, sharing fascinating facts and visuals. Therefore, raises awareness and inspires a deeper appreciation for biodiversity. This approach not only informs their audience about critical environmental topics but also engages them with captivating visuals and immediate content.
  • ESPN’s Sports Highlights uses Instagram Stories to deliver real-time sports highlights and updates. By sharing instant clips of game-winning moments, athlete interviews, and live event coverage, ESPN keeps its audience engaged with the latest in the sports world. The immediacy of Stories allows fans to stay connected with their favorite sports and teams, ensuring they never miss a crucial moment.

Using Instagram Stories for timely and breaking news not only keeps your audience informed but also fosters a sense of immediacy and connection. This strategy can enhance engagement and ensure that your followers are always in the loop with the latest updates.

Spur-of-the-Moment Updates

Instagram Stories are perfect for sharing quick, impromptu updates or statements that don’t necessarily fit the polished aesthetic of your post grid. The temporary and casual nature of Stories allows for more spontaneous and authentic communication with your audience.

Celebrities and TV Personalities Use Stories for Quick Updates

When comparing Instagram post vs story, many celebrities and TV personalities leverage Instagram Stories to provide their followers with spur-of-the-moment updates. These updates can range from personal thoughts and reactions to behind-the-scenes glimpses and real-time responses to current events. Stories provide a platform for these public figures to communicate more directly and intimately with their audience, creating a sense of immediacy and connection.

Example

  • Holly Willoughby’s Updates During Her Rift with Philip Schofield: Holly Willoughby used Instagram Stories to share quick updates and personal reflections during her publicized rift with fellow TV presenter Philip Schofield. This allowed her to address her followers directly and provide timely insights into her perspective, without the permanence or formality of a standard post.
  • Chrissy Teigen’s Daily Life Snippets: Chrissy Teigen is known for her active use of Instagram Stories to share snippets of her daily life, including cooking experiments, humorous observations, and family moments. These quick, informal updates allow her to maintain a relatable and authentic presence on social media, engaging her followers with a candid look into her everyday activities.
  • Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson’s Behind-the-Scenes Moments: Dwayne “The Rock” Johnson frequently uses Instagram Stories to share behind-the-scenes content from his movies, workouts, and personal life. These updates provide fans with an exclusive look at his routines and projects, enhancing the sense of connection and immediacy that keeps his audience engaged and invested in his content.

Using Instagram Stories for spur-of-the-moment updates allows for a more dynamic and authentic interaction with your audience, making it an invaluable tool for maintaining a lively and engaging social media presence.

Flash Sales

Sample flash sale

Instagram Stories are an effective tool for promoting flash sales and limited-time offers, creating a sense of urgency and excitement among your audience. The temporary nature of Stories aligns perfectly with the concept of short-term promotions, encouraging quick action from viewers.

Promote Limited-Time Offers and Sales

Instagram Stories highlighting flash sales and exclusive deals can boost engagement and drive immediate traffic. Stories allow you to create visually appealing and dynamic content that grabs attention quickly. Features such as countdown stickers, swipe-up links (for accounts with 10,000+ followers), and direct messaging options make it easy for followers to take immediate action on your offers.

Example

  • Liberty London’s Highlighted Stories: Liberty London effectively utilizes Instagram Stories to promote their flash sales and special offers. By highlighting these sales in their Stories, Liberty London creates a buzz and encourages followers to act fast to take advantage of limited-time discounts. The use of engaging visuals, countdown timers, and direct links to their online store enhances the shopping experience. It will drive sales during these promotional periods.

Promoting flash sales through Instagram Stories is a powerful way to generate excitement and urgency. Additionally, motivating your audience to engage with your brand and make purchases before the offers expire.

Tools for Instagram Posts & Stories

Effective scheduling and management of Instagram posts and stories are crucial for maintaining a consistent and engaging presence on the platform. By utilizing the right tools, you can help streamline your content strategy, ensuring that your posts, stories, and reels are published at optimal times for maximum engagement.

Furthermore, when evaluating Instagram post vs story, reporting and analytics tools provide detailed metrics on the reach and engagement of your Instagram content. Track impressions, likes, comments, shares, and saves for each post and story to get a comprehensive view of audience interactions. As a result, these insights help you understand what types of content resonate most with your audience, allowing you to refine your strategy accordingly.

Scheduling and Management

Scheduling your Instagram content in advance allows you to maintain a consistent posting schedule, which is key to keeping your audience engaged and growing your following. Here are some benefits and tools for scheduling:

  • Maximize Engagement: By scheduling your posts, stories, and reels, you can ensure they go live when your audience is most active. This increases the chances of higher engagement rates, as your content will appear when followers are most likely to see and interact with it.
  • Save Time: Scheduling tools enable you to batch-create content and plan your posts ahead of time. This efficiency allows you to focus on other aspects of your social media strategy, such as engagement and analytics.
  • Maintain Consistency: Consistency is crucial for building a loyal audience. Scheduling tools help you stick to a regular posting schedule, ensuring that your content is published consistently without gaps.
  • Plan Campaigns: Scheduling tools allow you to plan and execute marketing campaigns more effectively. You can align your content with promotional events, product launches, or seasonal themes, ensuring a cohesive and strategic approach.

Popular Scheduling Tools

  • Hootsuite robust platform supports scheduling across multiple social media accounts, including Instagram. It also offers analytics to help you measure the performance of your scheduled content.
  • Buffer provides a simple and intuitive interface for scheduling posts and stories. It also includes features like post previews and hashtag suggestions to optimize your content for better engagement.
  • Planoly is designed specifically for Instagram, offering a visual planner and scheduler for posts and stories. It also provides analytics to track your performance and insights to refine your strategy.

Maintain Consistency with the Content Calendar

A content calendar is a valuable tool for organizing and managing your Instagram strategy. It helps you plan your posts, stories, and reels ahead of time, maintaining a consistent posting schedule. Here’s how a content calendar can enhance your Instagram management:

  • Organization: A content calendar provides a clear overview of your planned content, helping you to organize posts by date, type, and theme. This ensures that you have a balanced mix of content and avoid last-minute scrambles for ideas.
  • Strategic Planning: With a content calendar, you can align your Instagram content with your broader marketing goals and campaigns. This includes planning around product launches, holidays, and other key events to maximize impact and relevance.
  • Consistency: Regular posting is key to keeping your audience engaged. A content calendar helps you maintain a consistent posting schedule, which is essential for building a loyal following. By planning ahead, you can ensure that you never miss a posting deadline.
  • Content Variety: Planning content in advance allows you to diversify your posts, stories, and reels. You can ensure a good mix of promotional content, educational posts, behind-the-scenes stories, and user-generated content to keep your feed interesting and engaging.
  • Collaboration: For teams managing Instagram accounts, a content calendar facilitates better collaboration. Team members can see the planned content, contribute ideas, and stay aligned on the content strategy.

Tools for Content Calendars

  • Trello is a versatile project management tool that can be customized to create a visual content calendar. You can create boards for different content types and schedule posts with due dates and checklists.
  • Asana offers a robust platform for planning and tracking content. You can create tasks for each post, assign them to team members, and set deadlines to ensure everything stays on track.
  • For a simple and straightforward approach, Google Calendar allows you to schedule your posts and stories, set reminders, and share the calendar with your team for seamless collaboration.

Therefore, by maintaining consistency with a content calendar, you can ensure that your Instagram content strategy is well-organized, strategically planned, and effectively executed, helping you build a strong and engaging presence on the platform.

Reporting and Analytics

Understanding and analyzing your Instagram performance is crucial for optimizing your content strategy and achieving your social media goals. The right tools provide insights into post and story performance, enabling data-driven decisions to boost engagement.

View Reach, Engagement Metrics, and ROI Insights

When comparing Instagram post vs story, reporting and analytics tools provide detailed metrics on the reach and engagement of your Instagram content. You can track the number of impressions, likes, comments, shares, and saves for each post and story, giving you a comprehensive view of your audience’s interactions. These insights help you understand what types of content resonate most with your audience, allowing you to refine your strategy accordingly. Additionally, tracking active times from WolfPack’s followers reflects variance between industries and brands on Instagram, offering deeper insights into when your specific audience is most engaged.

Active Times From WolfPack’s Followers Reflect Variance Between Industries/Brands
Active Times From WolfPack’s Followers Reflect Variance Between Industries/Brands

Additionally, understanding the Instagram algorithm is crucial. The algorithm prioritizes content from accounts that users engage with frequently and gives preference to content types like Reels and Stories that keep users on the platform longer. By leveraging these analytics and insights, you can align your content strategy with the algorithm to maximize visibility and engagement.

Additionally, when evaluating Instagram post vs story, these tools often provide ROI (Return on Investment) insights, which are essential for measuring the effectiveness of your campaigns. Analyzing ad performance helps determine ROI and optimize marketing spend.

The Instagram Algorithm

The Instagram algorithm generally favors consistent and engaging content. Here’s a more detailed guideline for how often to post both stories and feed posts on Instagram:

Instagram Stories

  • Frequency: At least once per day.
  • Optimal Frequency: 3-5 stories per day.
  • Why: Instagram Stories are designed to keep your audience engaged throughout the day. Posting multiple stories can help maintain visibility and interaction. Stories can showcase behind-the-scenes content, daily updates, polls, questions, and other interactive elements.

Instagram Posts

  • Frequency: 3-5 times per week.
  • Optimal Frequency: Once a day or every other day.
  • Why: Consistent feed posts help maintain your presence in the feed of your followers. Quality is crucial, so focus on high-quality images, videos, and captions that resonate with your audience. This frequency allows you to stay relevant without overwhelming your followers.

Best Practices for Posting

  • Consistency: Stick to a regular posting schedule to help the algorithm recognize your activity patterns and keep your content in front of your audience.
  • Engagement: Aim for posts that encourage likes, comments, shares, and saves. Engaging content performs better in the algorithm.
  • Timing: Post when your audience is most active. Use Instagram Insights to find the best times to post.
  • Variety: Mix different types of content (photos, videos, carousels) to keep your feed interesting and engaging.
  • Interactive Features: Use interactive features in stories like polls, quizzes, and question stickers to boost engagement.

    Track Mentions and Plan Story Schedules in Advance

    Analytics tools also enable you to track mentions of your brand across Instagram. Monitoring mentions helps you stay informed about how your brand is perceived and engaged with by your audience. It allows you to respond promptly to comments and feedback. Additionally, this will enhance your brand’s reputation and foster stronger relationships with your followers.

    Moreover, when considering an Instagram post vs story, these tools allow you to plan and schedule your stories in advance. Using analytics to identify the best times to post, you can ensure that your stories reach the maximum number of viewers. Planning your story schedule based on data-driven insights helps maintain a consistent presence and keeps your audience engaged.

    Popular Reporting and Analytics Tools

    • Built into the Instagram app, the Instagram Insights tool provides basic analytics for business profiles. Additionally, it also includes reach, impressions, and engagement metrics for posts and stories.
    • Hootsuite Analytics offers comprehensive analytics reports that cover a wide range of metrics. For example, from audience growth and engagement to ROI insights and performance trends.
    • Sprout Social provides advanced analytics and reporting features, including custom reports, trend analysis, and performance benchmarking against competitors.

    Conclusion

    When considering an Instagram post vs story, both can play crucial roles in your social media strategy. Understanding their unique benefits and aligning your usage with your brand’s goals and audience expectations is key. With the right approach, you can create a dynamic and engaging Instagram presence that resonates with your followers. Start managing your Instagram content effectively and see the difference it makes for your brand!

    Contact Wolfpack Advising today for expert guidance and tailored social media solutions to help your brand thrive. Visit Wolfpack Advising and take the first step towards a more impactful online presence!